Is South India Really Richer?

That South India is more developed than the Hindi-speaking North is a common refrain. Literacy rates and per capita income generally bear this out. Indeed, we worry of the barren villages in Bihar, not fertile landscapes across Tamil Nadu. As per the Human Development Indices across India, the South is just over 25% ahead of the All-India average.

And yet, the story is false. Or so is my conclusion after running into a few “Data Stories” of India (looks like Tyler Cowen is interested, too). While the maps give breathtaking life to the real depth of poverty across India, there are fairly rigorous analytics to vindicate my point. While the commonly-used GINI measure of inequality is very intuitive, it’s handcuffed by its inability to decompose the inequality with certain subgroups. A more appropriate measure is the Theil Index, which I talk about in a recent blog post:

The math behind the measure (between 0 and 1) requires a fair understanding of information theory but the idea is lower index implies a higher economic “entropy”.

Your physics teacher might tell you that this is a bad thing but, economically, it’s a little more complex. As Boltzmann showed, entropy increases as predictability of an event decreases. This means the entropy of a fair coin is higher than a biased one. Similarly, in a very equal economy it is very difficult to distinguish between two earners based only on their income. Indeed in a perfectly equal society this is impossible. However, as society stratifies itself, knowledge of ones income conveys far more information (redundancy), thereby decreasing entropy.

Within a system, Theil makes it easy for econometricians to understand the amount of total inequality due to within-group inequality and across-group inequality. If this is a little hard to grasp, think about it this way. If the total differences in economic output remained constant between countries (that is, India is still poor and Norway rich) but income was equally distributed within each country the residual inequality would be the “across-country” inequality. The residual from the converse, where all countries remain as unequal as they were, but world economic output is distributed equally to countries (not people), represents the “within-country” inequality.

And the same reasoning can be scaled-down to consider inequality within and across Indian states. And this is just what a few researchers from the University of Texas did. Before we discuss this, it’s worth considering what high” decomposed, across-state inequality is. A good benchmark is definitely America. While the Northeast and California are generally considered to be richer than the rest, the real turmoil of inequality – at least the public’s eye – is definitely between individuals and not states. Further, the economic relationship between various American regions has been highly volatile, with some sign that growth is picking up most rapidly (in no small part due to extractive oil and gas industries) across “middle America”. Here is a decomposed map of inequality in the United States:

Image

A few accounting points notes here – while the overall measure can never be negative (greyish or black, in the above figure) individual agents can. A below-zero value here indicates that the given county is actually decreasing overall inequality of the country as a whole. The signal, here, is that American states are, broadly, equal. The real inequality stems from the difference between the rich and poor in Manhattan, not between the New Yorker and Iowan.

So back to Galbraith, Chowdhury, and Shrivastava at Texas, we find that across-State inequality in India is pretty low:

Image

The dynamics of this graph are fascinating. For one, the purple line (within state inequality) is far more cyclical with overall inequality than the green line (between state inequality). While both do a fair job signalling inflections, the former represents approximately 90% of the change. Indeed, the contribution of between state inequality has been in relative decline since the 1980s.

While this chart is too fuzzy to derive any grand conclusions, it’s interesting that the correlation across between state and within state inequalities diminished significantly since the piecemeal reforms of the 1980s. While data isn’t available as far back as the ’50s, I suspect liberalization shifted the onus from the state onto the individual. Further, central bureaucrats weren’t able to throttle State growth in the same uneven manner as the years of Fabian regulation.

Of course, this is just mere conjecture. Here’s a graph from the Data Stories:

Image

It’s surprising how relatively rich Bangalore (the blue oasis straight up from the Southern tip) is. Generally, though, almost all of India is as deprived of all the assets indicated above. Now, some might say this isn’t a good depiction of wealth inequality across India because most of the inequality doesn’t stem from the upper-middle class that owns said assets, but among the poor. However, it’s important noting that in terms of total assets, the 5% that owns these assets controls most of Indian wealth. Division of what’s leftover barely moves overall inequality.

On the other hand, in terms of overall standard of living, the South might actually be significantly better:

Image

The big exception is that a good chunk of the North does as well if not better than the South. The cow-belt of India (it’s heartland) does remarkably badly. While this is commonly parsed as the relative wealth of the South, I think it’s the far more equitable distribution of the little that’s leftover after the 5% have taken their share. The above graph depicts what we may call the “poorest of the poor”. To that end, let’s reference this image against the Theil contributions of various states to overall inequality, again from Galbraith et al.:

Image

It should not be hard to see that there’s a fair overlap between the states listed on here (various incarnations of Maharashtra, West Bengal, Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, and Orissa) are the darkest on the map.

This has some important implications for policy making across India. Indians all over (especially in the anxious time before an election) hear of the Gujarat or Bihar “growth models”. Panagariya and Bhagwati in India’s Tryst with Destiny (which I critically review, here) talk about the importance of pro-growth policies. They fairly argue that redistribution alone cannot better the lives of India’s poor.

And while on a national stage this is definitely true, the data above clearly show that the more habitable states (in the economic sense) are not so because of rapid growth rates, but a more equitable distribution of income between the poor and the not-so-poor-but-not-rich. There are a few future research projects, in America, India, and the world that would be very interesting. The Theil Index is, econometrically, a far more robust measure capable of fantastic insight. It would be fascinating to see a study that decomposes a country not into States, but income percentiles to gauge the extent to which each contributes to overall inequality.

I’m guessing, within the United States, there has been an overwhelming shift in the past thirty years away from general inequality to that between the top 5%. In some sense, policy should be targeted to curing not just inequality, but also inequality of inequality.

 

Advertisements
64 comments
  1. Pingback: Assorted links

  2. Wonderful article. Clarifies some of the myths or misconceptions about measuring economic inequality.
    Thank you, Ashok.

    • Thanks for the comment! Yes, measuring economic inequality is very tricky, and the GINI is really a brute force that can obscure some important truths.

  3. The way we choose buy computer to see the report on his
    computer. Watch live streaming sky sports television
    online for free monthly fees. That free shipping may not apply to you if you
    buy in bulk also.

  4. Hey there! I’ve been reading your site for a long time now and finally got the courage to go ahead and give you a shout out from Dallas Tx!

    Just wanted to mention keep up the excellent work!

  5. This is really interesting, You are a very skilled blogger.
    I’ve joined your feed and look forward to seeking more of your wonderful post.
    Also, I’ve shared your site in my social
    networks!

  6. This website was… how do you say it? Relevant!!
    Finally I’ve found something which helped me. Cheers!

  7. Ilse said:

    If some one needs to be updated with latest technologies therefore he must be visit this web site and be up to date everyday.

  8. My brother suggested I might like this web site.
    He was entirely right. This post truly made my day. You cann’t imagine just how much time I
    had spent for this info! Thanks!

  9. Hi my loved one! I want to say that this article is amazing, great written and come with approximately
    all vital infos. I would like to look extra posts like this
    .

  10. Maryann said:

    I think that is one of the so much important information for me.
    And i’m happy reading your article. But wanna remark on few normal things, The site taste is perfect, the articles is really great :
    D. Good process, cheers

  11. Thanks for your marvelous posting! I actually enjoyed readiing it, you may be a great author.I will be sure
    to bookmark ylur blog and will come back at some point.
    I want to encourage you to continue your great writing,
    have a nice evening!

  12. Have you ever considered about including a little bit more than just
    your articles? I mean, what you say is important and all.
    Nevertheless imagine if you added some great photos or videos to
    give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with pics and videos, this website could certainly
    be one of the best in its field. Very good blog!

  13. An article around the size of this one calls for
    about twenty minutes to write, and a few minutes to post.
    If you do not already understand both customer service and marketing completely,
    you will want to invest some time learning about both before you think about starting as a work at home travel agent.
    Another technique you should steer clear of is blog commenting software.

  14. empire four kingdoms cheats said:

    I hope this short Seniorama Review will aid you to differentiate whether Seniorama is Scam or possibly a Real Deal.
    That can certainly be depleted with games, downloaded movies, other applications, music, photos, plus
    more. The Stereo setting produced decent music and sound for general listening, along with the
    ‘Game’ setting produced a unique subset of the previously mentioned echo
    chamber. That may be accounted for through the sometimes slow framerate that seemed draggy and extremely impacted the gameplay.
    While the Nokia 6151 is packed with 3G technology it can be to become blamed
    like a power guzzler. But again, the 360 was highly dependent on connection to the
    internet speed for quality so that it wasn. That’s all a youngster
    wants to do when coming back home at school right.
    Another quick party game for adults is Senior
    Moment. Often times folks are wiped out in a game considering
    that they’re simply standing there ready to get
    a gun to reload. The way the lights results work is additionally equally as unbelievable with colours from textures these kinds of since the sand changing in richness and
    color from wherever the cars viewpoint is. It helps take your brain off every single day stressors
    of life. These encounter effects cover everything from traps that you just stumble
    on, to events such as a goblin seeing your group and running away and
    off to get help. One in the negatives within this game is often a very long building time.
    As stated, styling is purely subjective so whether it changes your buy choices around you.
    Bring me – the bingo can be an ice breaker in each and every party.
    Sadly, though, it simply feels as though there’s so much more wrong with this
    game worth describing, yet it could probably just waste
    everyone’s time further discussing this atrocious piece of software.

    It provides the app along with a selection of alternate start button orbs
    you can try out. For example, you can find reviews on top games, top scores for the day and in many
    cases alerts to discounted gaming merchandise and games.
    where it is possible to earn gift cards, gifts or donate your points to charity.
    The game concepts act like Agricola, with all the give attention to obtaining and processing
    resources so that you can feed your workers and construct buildings.

    For example, Kara Thrace has access to the leadership, tactics and piloting skills.
    There may be the Main Departments track that improves
    as you successfully merge departments. The resource system has changed; in San Juan, in lieu
    of developing a separate currency resource, your building cards themselves
    are also the currency. You can start to play My Sims by sitting
    with whole family, as its gaming theme revolves too deeply around a household structure.
    The author statements to own cracked an assortment buying process which has helped developed far more lottery winners
    for the constant basis.

  15. angry birds transformers cheat tool said:

    Smiling is ofcause good, I love smiling, but everytime you smile you are giving out your power and this is a strategy for
    loosing status. The brain, then, shifts to feature the resolution like a Healing Phase.

    A week later, on August 25, ARES was reactivated, on account of more evacuations and
    the dependence on a shelter. Remember that this dog is very active and was originally bred to work.
    You might learn that they heard rumors which need dispelling.
    The volcano that may be spewing ash and lava for a long time blasted with major force soon, causing a dangerous situation. The search engine spiders will automatically
    keep returning and indexing your online pages like
    a precusor to subsequently ranking it around the SERPs. Now, referring to
    the title of the Article, I suppose some readers could be wondering if
    and when I plan to comment on the kerfuffle about Glenn Beck’s necessitate people to abandon their churches.
    It’s where the body hits the RED ALERT button and battens along the hatches ready to either fight or flee.
    The mental the signs of stress then result in behavioral symptoms including overeating, violent instances of anger or frequent bouts of escapism through drugs and alcohol because in the body and mind’s inability to deal with the continual bombardment
    of stress hormones. Hospital treatment costs are at an all-time high these days, especially
    for foreign visitors. It was so stressful to the children who took these tests
    that in some instances they cried, vomited or
    lost control of their bowels or bladders even though some just
    gave up. quickly which triage is carried out quickly and accurately.
    That’s why it’s very crucial that you make sure that
    you’re putting your cash in firms that hold the wherewithal to live
    to the long-term. These feelings are indicating that conditioned thought patterns are stopping you moving forward from more which is
    wanting to become expressed inside of you. When you permit a
    specific thing to get quarantine, Windows Defender will still notify
    you within the notification division of Windows
    so that you can review the detected items. When she stopped levitating, she
    wrote her resignation letter and sent it on the Head Sister.
    Stay focused, break it down, parents, communicate your preferences, and let others take over or help
    you. Some might show the remaining charge as near full capacity with green indicator.
    Do certain fabrics bother him because they’re scratchy.
    The biggest reason why people forget stop losses is through short-term fluctuations available price.
    The problem with the gates should not deter a determined
    commander, and also the Soviets are waiting to gain back charge of certainly one of their most crucial
    cities. What your spouse is hinting is that she’s left or is close to throwing
    in the towel on your marriage. Upper respiratory infections (URI) have been fatal for any cavy.
    If the thing is the scales tipping towards danger zone then rather than waiting on your red alert weight,
    or worse ten pounds past this flag, begin making changes immediately.

  16. I enjoy looking through a post thwt will make people think.

    Also, thank you for allowing for me to comment!

  17. Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it’s really
    informative. I am gonna watch out for brussels. I’ll appreciate if
    you continue this in future. Lots of people
    will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  18. Link exchange is nothing else however it is simply placing the other person’s blog link on your page at proper place and other
    person will also do similar in support of you.

  19. Paul said:

    Hi, after reading this remarkable article i am also
    delighted to share my familiarity here with friends.

  20. The players in the wolves of wall street host plenty of despicable men, who’re entertainig us like we’re a part in a comedy show.
    The children’s initial reservation of having Maria soon melts away, as she teaches them to appreciate the beauty of life and music.
    To obtain a person star, you’ve got to attain approximately one hundred twenty,000 points.

  21. hello there and thank you for your info – I’ve certainly picked up anything new
    from right here. I did however expertise a few technical issues using this
    site, since I experienced to reload the site lots of times previous to I
    could get it to load correctly. I had been wondering if
    your hosting is OK? Not that I am complaining, but slow loading
    instances times will very frequently affect your placement in google and can damage your quality score if ads and marketing with Adwords.
    Well I am adding this RSS to my email and could look out for a lot more of your respective interesting content.
    Make sure you update this again soon.

  22. Hi! Do you know if they make any plugins to safeguard against hackers?
    I’m kinda paranoid about losing everything I’ve worked hard on. Any tips?

  23. Hi Dear, are you in fact visiting this web site regularly, if so then you will absolutely take pleasant knowledge.

  24. Wilfred said:

    I am genuinely haƿpy to read this webpage posts which consists of lots of helpful data, thanks for prοviding these kinds οf information.

  25. I have read so many content on the topic of the
    blogger lovers except this article is actually a fastidious piece of
    writing, keep it up.

  26. Aw, this was an incredibly good post. Spending some time and actual effort to produce a good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate a whole lot and don’t manage to get nearly anything done.

  27. Hello! Would you mind if I share your blog with my twitter group?
    There’s a lot of people that I think would really enjoy your content.
    Please let me know. Cheers

  28. Whats up very cool site!! Man .. Excellent .. Wonderful ..
    I will bookmark your blog and take the feeds
    additionally? I’m satisfied to seek out so many useful information right here in the publish, we’d like
    work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing.
    . . . . .

  29. Unquestionably consider that which you stated. Your favorite reason appeared to be on the web the easiest factor to take into accout of.

    I say to you, I certainly get irked at the same time as folks
    consider concerns that they plainly don’t realize about.
    You managed to hit the nail upon the highest and also outlined out the entire
    thing without having side effect , people could take a signal.
    Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

  30. I’m not sure why but this blog is loading extremely slow for me.

    Is anyone else having this issue or is it a problem on my
    end? I’ll check back later on and see if the problem still exists.

  31. Everyone loves what you guys are usually up too. This kind of clever work and coverage!
    Keep up the awesome works guys I’ve included you guys to blogroll.

  32. It’s really a cool and helpful piece of info. I’m glad that you simply shared this useful info with us.
    Please keep us informed like this. Thank you for sharing.

  33. Good post. I learn something totally new and challenging
    on websites I stumbleupon every day. It’s always interesting to
    read content from other authors and practice a little something
    from their sites.

  34. I like the valuable information you provide in your articles.
    I’ll bookmark your blog and check again here regularly.
    I’m quite certain I will learn many new stuff right here! Good luck for the next!

  35. Carole said:

    If you are going for most excellent contents like myself, just
    visit this web page daily for the reason that it provides quality contents, thanks

  36. Hi it’s me, I am also visiting this website regularly, this web site is really
    good and the people are really sharing pleasant thoughts.

  37. Have you ever thought about adding a little bit more than just your articles?

    I mean, what you say is fundamental and all.

    However think of if you added some great photos or videos
    to give your posts more, “pop”! Your content is excellent but with images and video clips, this blog
    could undeniably be one of the greatest in its field.

    Fantastic blog!

  38. ӏf some one needs expert view about blogging and site-bսilding then i propose him/her tо ƿay a
    visit this web site, Keep up the good wօrk.

  39. I am regular visitor, how are you everybody? This piece of writing posted at this website is in fact
    pleasant.

  40. Hi there colleagues, its great post regarding cultureand fully explained, keep it up all the
    time.

  41. Hmm is anyone else having problems with the images on this blog loading?
    I’m trying to figure out if its a problem on my end or if it’s the blog.
    Any responses would be greatly appreciated.

  42. I am truly grateful to the owner of this website who has shared this fantastic post
    at at this time.

  43. Magnificent goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you’re just extremely wonderful. I really like what you have acquired here, certainly like what you are saying and the way in which you say it. You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it smart. I can’t wait to read much more from you. This is actually a great site.

  44. Netminder Kerrin Sperry had 14 boston limousiine
    stops. It put a shame on the entryway walls.

  45. Marcos said:

    For more information about our services, please give us a call or send us email to call you back.
    I suggest you to have Core i7 and good amount of RAM, about 6
    gigs and also any entry level graphic card won’t do any harm.
    Moreover, this would put a restraint to employees decorous destroyed out or overworked.

  46. That is very interesting, You’re a very skilled blogger.

    I’ve joined your rss feed and sit up for in quest of more of your
    excellent post. Additionally, I’ve shared your site in my social networks

  47. Hey there, I think your blog might be having
    browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Chrome,
    it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping.
    I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, awesome blog!

  48. The most important pyramid in Caracol, “Canaa” (Sky Place),
    stands 143 feet high, making it is the tallest man-made construction in all of Belize.

  49. There are many RAD (Fast Software Improvement) Tools accessible for sport creation, a lot of which
    are available at no cost on-line.

  50. I visit each day some blogs and websites to read posts, except this webpage offers feature based
    posts.

  51. You like that wuld appropriately suit all your exectations and provide itt with devvice policies.
    Butt we’ve got the website 1 GHz CPU unit that sholuld
    do is look at it. Selection made using website the standard
    QWERTY keyboard. You can also gain advanced knowledge from other website applications.
    After the implementation of Volley, or uskng the
    keyboard also. Andd that’s it for developers, foor the desktop with a
    large2. If yyou haven’t got a Web view inside a browser.

  52. Hmm it seems like your website ate my first comment (it was super long) so
    I guess I’ll just sum it up what I wrote and say, I’m thoroughly
    enjoying your blog. I as well am an aspiring blog blogger but I’m still new to the
    whole thing. Do you have any helpful hints for rookie blog
    writers? I’d definitely appreciate it.

  53. Hey there! I know this is inda off topic nevertheless I’d figured I’d ask.
    Would you be interested in exchanging links orr maybe guest autthoring a blog post or vice-versa?
    My site goes over a lot of the same tkpics as yours and I feel we could
    greatly benefit from each other. If you’re interested feel free to send
    me an email. I look forward tto hearing from you! Awesome blog by the way!

  54. Aside from the sexy women when you look at the scenes, you will definitely notice the
    greatest shots taken aided by the best cameras when you look at the movie industry.
    With Bluestone, Probate Court offices can create forms and workflows as well as access and edit records on the fly
    within one turnkey system. Recently, Blogger changed its terms of use
    and banned all adult websites from its directory.

  55. sam said:

    South is really ahead brother. The richest city in India is Bangalore, the richest state is GOA, the state with highest HDI is Kerala. The IT capital of India is in Karnataka, the Detroit of Asia is Chennai, the R&D capital and the Hi-Tech city of India is Hyderabad. There are three major metros in four states in south. North, East and west has only one each. All the states in South are developed and at the same time majority of the states in North are underdeveloped. Majority of the slums and poor people lives in North. Half of the employment and more than 30% of economy is produced by south. By any means South is much ahead of any other parts of India. South did all of these without any government support. North even though is a seat of central government, it failed.

  56. Jerry said:

    ashokarao.com has potential, you can make
    your site go viral easily using one tricky method.
    Just type in google:
    Isud’s Method To Go Viral

  57. LMAO what a defensive&emotionally driven article! it clearly shows that the author is emotionally insecure and can’t come into terms with the FACT that South is far ahead of north in almost literally EVERYTHING! literacy,infrastructure,per capita&nominal GDP,Industrial&urban development,healthcare you name it!

    The ONLY thing South India is lagging behind in is the fertility rates it seems(Not that its a bad thing).

    “big exception is that a good chunk of the North does as well if not better than the South.”
    Good chunk? Madhya pradesh,U.P,Bihar&Rajasthan are “Good chunks” of North India and they’re horribly behind the South and no NONE of the Northern States actually “surpass” South.. the T.N&Kerela map is literally all light.

    “cow-belt of India (it’s heartland”
    LOL wut? since when is the cowbelt “heartland” of India? what a load of baloney! the remote N.E India is just as important as the supposed “Heartland”!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s